URGENT UPDATE: A new video just dropped, comparing three all-in-one zoom lenses for Sony full-frame cameras, and it’s a must-watch for photographers looking to make an informed decision right now. The lenses in question span the critical 20-200mm range, a popular choice for everything from family events to travel photography.
In this concise analysis, photographer Abbott breaks down the strengths and weaknesses of each lens, including pricing that ranges from $800 for the older model to $999 for the high-end Sigma. The video highlights how these lenses perform in real-world situations, not just on paper, making it essential viewing for anyone considering an upgrade.
Abbott kicks off with the Sigma, noted for its impressive 10x zoom range starting at 20mm and reaching up to 200mm. However, he warns that this wide-angle comes with significant drawbacks, including noticeable distortion and vignetting at the lower end. With a f/5.6 aperture at 51mm, this lens may not be ideal for indoor or low-light conditions.
Next, Abbott turns his attention to the newer Tamron lens, which aims to strike a balance between performance and quality. He notes it begins slightly wider than 28mm while maintaining superior optical quality, with minimal barrel distortion compared to the Sigma. With better weather sealing and a robust build, this lens offers customization options through a USB-C port, allowing photographers to tailor it to their shooting style.
The older Tamron lens still holds its ground despite being phased out of new stock. Abbott emphasizes its brightness, staying away from f/5.6 until around 147mm, which can be a game-changer for photographers needing to keep ISO in check during challenging lighting conditions. However, he cautions that the 28mm field of view may not suffice for tight spaces compared to the Sigma’s wider angle.
Abbott’s recommendations are clear, but he provides critical side-by-side comparisons that reveal how each lens handles distortion, vignetting, and autofocus performance in dynamic environments. This visual evidence is vital for those trying to weigh factors like maximum width, brightness, and overall value.
As the photography community eagerly discusses these insights, viewers are encouraged to check out the full video for a comprehensive look at which lens might suit their needs best. Alex Cooke, a Cleveland-based photographer and meteorologist, underscores the importance of understanding these choices, especially for those who want to maximize their shooting experience.
This video not only informs but also engages the community, prompting discussions among photographers about their preferences and experiences with these lenses. Stay tuned for further updates as the lens market continues to evolve.
