URGENT UPDATE: A contentious vote in the House of Representatives on October 25, 2023, has resulted in a narrow approval of a bill that would make transgender medical treatments for minors a federal crime. The final tally was 216 to 211, igniting fierce debate across party lines and within party ranks regarding the future of transgender care for youth.
The legislation, which imposes severe criminal penalties, could see doctors who perform transgender-affirming surgeries on minors facing up to 10 years in prison. Additionally, prescribing puberty blockers to anyone under 18 would also be criminalized, potentially prosecuting parents who consent to or facilitate such treatments.
Democrats overwhelmingly rejected the bill, arguing that it infringes on parental rights and medical autonomy. Lawmakers expressed outrage, with the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) condemning the measure as an extreme overreach. Mike Zamore, the National Director of Policy & Government Affairs at the ACLU, stated,
“This extreme bill puts the threat of prosecution between hundreds of thousands of families and their doctors and would put doctors behind bars for exercising their best medical judgment.”
On the other hand, Republican supporters maintain that the bill is essential to safeguard children. Rep. Nancy Mace of South Carolina delivered a passionate defense, labeling current treatment practices as “obscene” and “disgusting.” She accused Democrats of endorsing what she termed “grooming of children,” insisting that “no child is born in the wrong body.”
Notably, there were instances of bipartisan crossover during the vote. Three Democrats — Vicente Gonzales (TX), Don Davis (NC), and Henry Cuellar (TX) — joined Republicans in support of the bill, while four GOP lawmakers — Mike Kennedy (UT), Brian Fitzpatrick (PA), Gabe Evans (CO), and Mike Lawler (NY) — voted against it.
As the bill moves to the Senate, its future remains uncertain. While Republicans hold the majority, it is unclear if Senate leadership will prioritize advancing the legislation. Observers are now watching closely to see if enough support exists to push it through.
This legislative battle highlights the ongoing national debate over transgender rights and healthcare access for minors, reflecting broader societal divisions on these issues. The implications of this vote could have lasting effects on families, medical professionals, and the rights of transgender individuals across the country.
Stay tuned for further updates as this story develops.
