Emil Pagliarulo, a lead writer at Bethesda, recently shared insights into the storytelling differences between the fantasy role-playing game (RPG) series, Elder Scrolls, and the sci-fi RPG series, Fallout. Speaking with GamesRadar+, he highlighted the complexity of narratives in Fallout compared to the more straightforward storytelling found in Elder Scrolls.
Pagliarulo noted that while both series involve intricate decision-making, Fallout often presents players with morally ambiguous choices. In games like Fallout: New Vegas, players encounter a multitude of factions, each with its own agenda, making it difficult to discern the most ethical path. He remarked, “I think it’s easier in a fantasy game like The Elder Scrolls, where a lot of fantasy tropes are ‘there’s a big bad evil.'”
In contrast, Fallout showcases a world filled with “shades of gray.” Pagliarulo emphasized that players must grapple with complex moral dilemmas. For example, in Fallout 4, the factions of the Brotherhood of Steel and the Institute challenge players to consider their motives. He stated, “No matter what they do, you have to sit back and go ‘maybe they have a point’.”
Pagliarulo raised philosophical questions surrounding the Institute, asking, “Are the synths just really toasters? Are they just machines? We created them, do they deserve to have freedom?” He also questioned the ethics of the Brotherhood of Steel, suggesting that while they may appear harsh, humanity’s control over technology raises significant concerns.
The depth of storytelling in Fallout not only enhances player engagement but also encourages reflection on real-world issues. Pagliarulo’s comments resonate with fans who appreciate the series’ ability to provoke thought while navigating the post-apocalyptic landscape.
While the intricate narratives of Fallout may be challenging, they also contribute to the franchise’s allure. As players immerse themselves in their fifth playthrough of New Vegas, they continue to explore the moral complexities that define this iconic series.
