Ashley Tisdale’s departure from her friend group, which includes notable figures like Hilary Duff and Mandy Moore, has been attributed to claims of her “toxic” behavior. According to an exclusive report from The U.S. Sun, tensions within the group escalated over several years, leading to a significant fallout that has left many questioning the dynamics of their relationships.
A source close to the former circle revealed that Tisdale, 40, had been “slowly slipping away for years.” The discord reportedly deepened due to diverging political views and Tisdale’s perceived lack of support during personal crises faced by her friends. A pivotal moment occurred during the devastating wildfires in Los Angeles in January 2025, when multiple members of the group were significantly affected. The source stated, “Ashley hardly checked in” during this critical time and did not offer assistance, which left her friends feeling neglected.
The source further noted that Tisdale’s self-absorption appeared to increase, making it difficult for her friends to maintain a balanced friendship. “It seemed like she was only interested in things that benefited her,” the insider commented. This sentiment was echoed by Mandy Moore, who suffered personal losses during the wildfires, including the destruction of her home.
Political disagreements also contributed to the rift, with the source claiming that Tisdale’s social media posts and comments on political issues made some friends uncomfortable. This created a “toxic dynamic” that led to questions about her morals and beliefs. The fallout reportedly mirrors similar experiences faced by Vanessa Hudgens, Tisdale’s former co-star, who also drifted away for similar reasons.
In a recent blog post for The Cut, Tisdale addressed her feelings of exclusion from the group. The piece, titled “You’re Allowed To Leave Your Mom Group,” outlined her experiences of being left out and feeling “totally lost.” She reflected on the emotional toll this had taken, stating, “Maybe I’m not cool enough? All of a sudden, I was in high school again, feeling totally lost as to what I was doing wrong to be left out.”
Tisdale shared that after repeated instances of exclusion, she decided to distance herself from the group. She conveyed her decision to the other members, stating, “This is too high school for me, and I don’t want to take part in it anymore.” The reaction from her friends varied; some attempted to mend fences, while others did not acknowledge her feelings.
This situation highlights the complex nature of personal relationships, particularly among public figures navigating fame and friendship. Tisdale’s experience serves as a reminder of the emotional challenges that can arise even in seemingly supportive social circles. As these dynamics unfold, it raises questions about accountability and the importance of communication in maintaining healthy friendships. The U.S. Sun has reached out to Tisdale’s representatives for further comment on the matter.
