Governor Maura Healey of Massachusetts faces increasing scrutiny for a series of contradictory statements made over the years. As her policies and comments come under the spotlight, a collection of her most notable remarks has sparked debate about her leadership and accountability. This retrospective highlights her evolving positions, particularly concerning energy infrastructure, criminal justice, and social issues.
In recent discussions about natural gas pipelines, Healey’s statements from 2022 and 2025 raise questions about consistency. In 2022, she claimed on National Panhandler Radio, “Remember, I stopped two gas pipelines from coming into this state.” Fast forward to 2025, she denied having taken that action, stating, “First of all, I didn’t do that.” Her comments reflect a changing narrative that many are finding difficult to reconcile.
Healey’s stance on energy tariffs has also shifted. In 2025, she suggested that former President Donald Trump should remove tariffs on aluminum and steel, arguing that high costs hinder the development of energy infrastructure. This statement contrasts with her earlier criticisms of Trump’s energy policies, showcasing a complex relationship with the former president’s administration.
The governor’s handling of public safety issues, particularly regarding the treatment of vulnerable populations, has been equally controversial. In 2024, after a tragic incident involving a disabled girl, Healey remarked, “It is unfortunate that from time to time, things will happen.” When pressed about measures to prevent similar incidents, she cited her administration’s attempt to conduct criminal background checks on shelter residents. However, she later acknowledged that these checks were not implemented across all sites, calling the oversight “absolutely unacceptable.”
Healey’s remarks on gender identity and restroom policies have also drawn criticism. During a 2016 State House hearing, she infamously told women concerned about sharing restrooms with transgender individuals, “If you’ve got that much of a problem, ‘Hold it!’” This comment has been cited as dismissive of legitimate concerns regarding safety and privacy.
The governor’s responses to civil unrest have likewise raised eyebrows. In June 2020, amid nationwide protests, she told the Greater Boston Chamber of Commerce, “Yes, America is burning, but that’s how forests grow.” This metaphor drew backlash for appearing to downplay the severity of the situation.
Healey’s appointments have also stirred controversy. In November 2023, she appointed Monica Tibbets-Nutt as the state’s secretary of transportation, praising her as a “proven leader.” However, this followed shortly after the resignation of Tibbets-Nutt’s predecessor in the wake of a scandal involving a $900 million project on the Massachusetts Turnpike.
Her political endorsements have not gone unnoticed either. Healey supported Rachael Rollins for US Attorney in 2021, declaring her commitment to reforming the criminal justice system. Following Rollins’ resignation in 2023 due to misconduct, Healey’s silence on the matter raised questions about her judgment in selecting allies.
The governor’s handling of issues related to illegal immigration has also been contentious. When asked in November 2024 about supporting Trump’s immigration policies, Healey stated, “Absolutely not.” Yet, by May 2025, she acknowledged that some of Trump’s measures “make a lot of sense.” This inconsistency has left voters wondering where she truly stands on immigration reform.
As Healey navigates her role, her past remarks and decisions will likely continue to shape public perception. Her evolving positions on critical issues reflect a complex and often contradictory political landscape. As her term progresses, many will be watching closely for further developments and potential “greatest hits” as her tenure unfolds.
