Despite its reputation for producing high-quality programming, HBO Max has seen several of its acclaimed shows fade into obscurity shortly after release. According to entertainment journalist Cathal Gunning, many viewers have overlooked series such as The Sex Lives of College Girls and Pretty Little Liars even moments after they debuted on the platform. This phenomenon is not unique to HBO Max; it reflects a broader trend in the streaming industry where an overwhelming influx of content can overshadow even the most well-crafted series.
The streaming landscape has become highly competitive, with platforms like Netflix and Apple TV also struggling to keep audiences engaged. Gunning points out that HBO Max has produced a diverse array of shows since its launch, with some achieving significant acclaim while others have gone unnoticed despite their quality.
Hacks: A Sharp Satire
One standout series, Hacks, centers on veteran comedian Deborah Vance, portrayed by Jean Smart, and her young protégé Ava Daniels, played by Hannah Einbinder. This show business satire expertly balances humor and depth, appealing to audiences without becoming overly self-indulgent. Despite earning four consecutive nominations for the Primetime Emmy Award for Outstanding Comedy Series—and winning in its third season—Hacks has struggled to reach a wider viewer base.
The series features an impressive lineup of guest stars, including Margaret Cho and Patton Oswalt, which enhances its appeal. Yet, it remains a hidden gem rather than a mainstream success.
Gremlins: An Animated Prequel
Beginning in May 2023, Gremlins serves as a prequel to the classic horror-comedy franchise. Despite its kid-friendly animation, it captures the original’s subversive humor, making it appealing to both longtime fans and new viewers. The show boasts a talented cast, including Matthew Rhys and Ming-Na Wen, yet it has not garnered the attention it deserves since its debut. Critically well-received, the series still faces an uphill battle for recognition among fans, who seem more focused on the potential for a third live-action film.
Full Circle: A Thrilling Mystery
Released in 2023, Full Circle is a mystery drama that challenges viewers to engage closely with its intricate narrative. Directed by Steven Soderbergh and written by Ed Solomon, the series dissects a botched kidnapping from multiple perspectives. With a stellar cast, including Claire Danes and Timothy Olyphant, the show weaves a complex tale that rewards repeat viewings. Despite its narrative depth and critical acclaim, it has not captured the mainstream attention it merits.
Pretty Little Liars: A Bold Reimagining
The reboot of Pretty Little Liars, which premiered in July 2022, sparked skepticism among fans of the original series. While the original show’s finale received mixed reviews, the new version offers a fresh and darker take, featuring more mature themes and a bloodier tone. Despite initial reservations regarding its R-rated content, the reboot has proven to be an inventive and engaging experience for those willing to embrace its twists. However, it faced an abrupt cancellation in September 2024, leaving many fans disappointed.
The Sex Lives of College Girls
Developed by Mindy Kaling, The Sex Lives of College Girls offers a humorous, female-centric perspective on college life. This raunchy comedy, which debuted in 2021, tackles themes often explored in male-dominated college films but with a fresh twist. Featuring breakout stars such as Renee Rapp and Amrit Kaur, the series combines humor with candid storytelling. Despite its vibrant energy and relatable themes, it has not received the recognition it deserves within the streaming landscape.
Raised By Wolves: An Ambitious Sci-Fi Exploration
No discussion of underrated HBO Max shows would be complete without mentioning Raised By Wolves. Premiering in 2020, this ambitious sci-fi drama, directed by Ridley Scott, follows two androids raising human children on a distant planet after Earth’s destruction. The series delves into profound themes of faith and human nature, providing a thought-provoking viewing experience. Unfortunately, its unconventional pacing and heavy themes limited its appeal, resulting in a lack of mainstream recognition despite its substantial budget and critical acclaim.
As HBO Max continues to develop and release a variety of content, it remains to be seen whether these standout shows will eventually find their audiences. For now, they serve as a testament to the vast potential of storytelling within the streaming era, even as they linger in relative obscurity.
